1. "Everything We Were Has Become What We Are" - 2:59
2. "Poetically Pathetic" - 3:22
3. "Gone So Young" - 3:25
4. "Save Me from Me" - 2:48
5. "Postcards" - 3:11
6. "For What It's Worth" - 3:34
7. "The Right to Write Me Off" - 3:19
8. "The Sky Could Fall Tonight" - 3:41
9. "Falling Away" - 3:01
10. "Always You (Good Times)" - 4:09
11. "If I Fall" - 3:56
12. "Can't Hold Back" - 3:34

Además de las canciones ya mencionadas, la Edición de Lujo contiene las siguientes canciones:

1. "Leaving What You Wanted" - 3:39
2. "Falling Away (Demo)" - 2:59
3. "Gone So Young (Acoustic)" - 3:42
4. "Poetically Pathetic (Acoustic)" - 3:15
5. "Save Me from Me (Acoustic)" - 3:13
6. "For What It's Worth (Acoustic)" - 3:34
7. "Always You (Acoustic)" - 4:14