Drake recibió varios premios por su trabajo en cómics, incluido el premio Alley de 1967 a la mejor historia completa ("Who's Been Lying in My Grave?" en Strange Adventures #205 con Carmine Infantino), el premio Alley de 1967 a la mejor tira nueva ("Deadman" con Carmine Infantino en Strange Adventures), ^[3]​ y un premio Inkpot en 1999. ^[4]​

En 2005, Drake recibió el primer premio anual Bill Finger a la excelencia en la escritura de cómics. ^[5]​ En 2008, fue incluido póstumamente en el Salón de la Fama del Cómic Will Eisner. ^[6]​

• Adventure Comics #430 (1973)
• The Adventures of Bob Hope #88, 90–103, 105–109 (1964–1968)
• The Adventures of Jerry Lewis #83–98, 100–105, 115 (1964–1969)
• Batman #103, 105, 117, 124, 132, 154 (1956–1963)
• Blackhawk #196–198, 213 (1964–1965)
• Challengers of the Unknown #27, 29, 32, 38, 40, 45, 48, 55–63 (1962–1968)
• DC Special Series #12 (Secrets of Haunted House Special); #22 (G.I. Combat Special) (1978–1980)
• Doom Patrol #86–121 (1964–1968)
• The Fox and the Crow #96–98, 100–102, 106–108 (Stanley and His Monster) (1966–1968)
• Ghosts #108 (1982)
• G.I. Combat #228, 232–233, 239, 248, 255, 257, 264, 271, 273, 276 (1981–1985)
• Hawkman #24 (1968)
• House of Mystery #51–52, 247, 252, 254, 257, 261, 281 (1956–1980)
• House of Secrets #107, 115, 154 (1973–1978)
• The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis #25–26 (1964)
• My Greatest Adventure #80–85 (Doom Patrol) (1963–1964)
• Mystery in Space #115–116 (1981)
• Phantom Stranger vol. 2 #27–34, 37 (1973–1975)
• Plastic Man #1–10 (1966–1968)
• Plop! #19 (1976)
• Sea Devils #17 (1964)
• Secrets of Haunted House #5, 9, 31, 35, 39 (1975–1981)
• Showcase #1 (Fireman Farrell); #41–42, 44, 46–47 (Tommy Tomorrow) (1956–1963)
• Stanley and His Monster #109–110, 112 (1968)
• Star Spangled War Stories #193, 198 (1975–1976)
• Strange Adventures #205–206 (Deadman) (1967)
• Superboy #168 (1970)
• Supergirl #5–6 (1973)
• Superma's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #133 (1973)
• Tales of the Unexpected #40–71, 73–77 (Space Ranger) (1959–1963)
• Time Warp #3–5 (1980)
• The Unexpected #206, 209, 211–212, 217, 220, 222 (1981–1982)
• Weird War Tales #12–13, 15–16, 18–20, 22, 31, 36–37, 55–57, 69 (1973–1978)
• Weird Western Tales #20 (Jonah Hex) (1973)
• World's Finest Comics #102 (Tommy Tomorrow) (1959)

• Captain Savage and his Leatherneck Raiders ' #5, 13–16 (1968–1969)
• Captain Marvel #5–12 (1968–1969)
• Marvel Super-Heroes #18 (Guardians of the Galaxy), #19 (Ka-Zar) (1969)
• Not Brand Echh #11–13 (1968–1969)
• Sgt. Fury and his Howling Commandos #58 (1968)
• X-Men #47–54 (1968–1969)

• Arnold Drake at Mike's Amazing World of Comics
• Arnold Drake at the Unofficial Handbook of Marvel Comics Creators